Connect with us

Education

The Private University as Enterprise: Limits of Academic Capitalism

Published

on

Share

By Jibrin Ibrahim

Last week, I attended a Convening on Higher Education in Africa, organised by Professor Toyin Falola of the University of Texas at Austin. The conference held at Babcock University and focused on the theme of the impact of private universities on public universities in Africa.

Participants were drawn from university faculty, Academic Staff Union of Universities (ASUU), education regulators, founders, donors, students, and independent researchers from Ghana, Kenya, Uganda, South Africa, and Nigeria.
It was an exciting debate on the complex relationship between the public and private sectors in higher education.

The original argument for the establishment of private universities was to create more access for students but the reality today is that the private sector has not substantially increased access. In addition, private universities have not really recruited and trained their own faculty, they poaches from the public sector for staff and are dependent on moonlighting. The terrible story that has emerged is that many public university lecturers that are rarely seen by their students go to teach students in the private sector with assiduity and devotion for the extra money. The raison d’être of private universities, at least in Nigeria, is that public universities are perpetually on strike and parents need universities where their children can study, fully covering the syllabus and not spending more than the required number of years before graduation. This is being achieved and already the age of graduands of private universities is significantly lower than that of the public sector.

Nigeria currently has a total of 198 universities, half of which, 99, are private. The private universities however host only about 10 per cent of the total students in the country. The breakdown of the universities is as follows:

45 Federal Universities with 1,310,825 students = 62.4 per cent.

54 State Universities with 578,936 students = 27.5 per cent.

55 Private (Christian) Universities with 98,358 students = 4.68 per cent.

5 Private (Muslim) Universities with 29,984 students = 1.4 per cent.

39 Private (Secular) Universities with 81,908 students = 3.9 per cent.

A couple of years ago, we carried out research with the Institute of Education of the University of London on universities as a public good in Nigeria, Ghana, Kenya, South Africa and Uganda. Our findings showed a deep commitment by the governments and people of these countries to higher education as a public good that the state should bear responsibility for. The system worked as an elite model up till the 1980s, when the demand for access grew and in the process of rapid and significant expansion, massification developed. The governing elites in these countries responded with their feet, taking their children out of public sector universities on the grounds that quality had fallen, and sending them abroad. Those who could not afford foreign universities demanded for the establishment of private universities in their countries and the outcome is a two-tier system, essentially separating the children of the elite from those of the general people.

At the Babcock Conference, Dr Hannah Muzee of the University of Cape Town described this era we are in as one of academic capitalism, because many of the proprietors of private universities conceive of their organisations as enterprises that provide a service but should also produce profit. The consensus at the conference is that in Nigeria, not all private universities see their mission as profit making. Nonetheless, they are seen as enterprises that should, at least, break even. So far, that is not happening. Most private universities are making heavy losses. The reason is simple. I discussed with a number of proprietors and Vice Chancellors of private universities and their story is that the student base they have is too small to support the huge land acquisition, infrastructure development, security, construction and bank loan costs that they have incurred. In the coming years, many will collapse as bankrupt businesses, because although they charge high fees, the fees are too low to support their costs.

The real problematic they face is not with public universities in Nigeria. The Nigerian university system is complex and class based and operates in an international environment in which many within the elite send their children abroad for their education. According to the United Kingdom’s Higher Education Statistics Agency (HESA), Nigeria was the third non-European Union country sending the highest number of students to the UK. In 2009/10, it had 16,680 students in its higher institutions and in 2010/11, there were 17,585 Nigerian students in those institutions, ranking only behind India and China. The United Kingdom has been actively soliciting for Nigerian fee-paying students for decades, with each student paying, on average, £12,000 each just for tuition. It was the former governor of the Central Bank of Nigeria, Muhammadu Sanusi II, who first drew attention to the cost of education of elite children abroad. He said there were about 71,000 Nigerian students in Ghanaian tertiary institutions and they spent about US$1 billion on tuition and upkeep at that time: “The tuition paid by Nigerian students studying in Ghana with a better organised education system is more than the annual budget of all federal universities in the country.”

A fraction of the amount spent by the elite on their children abroad would be enough to adequately fund higher education in Nigeria. This is what led us to the current paradox in which progressive Nigerians insist that the government must fully fund public universities, but as the elite know that the university system is broken, they vote with their feet and send their children abroad for university education. According to the International Educational Exchange data released by the Institute of International Education (IIE), there were 11,710 Nigerian students pursuing their educational goals in the United States in 2017. When you add the numbers of Nigerian students in Malaysia, Canada, South Africa, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Hungary, India, Turkey, Ukraine, Russia, Cyprus and Germany, it is easy to see why private universities in Nigeria have been squeezed out of resources. There is a political economy crisis generated by the fact that the Nigerian elite place massive amounts of money in foreign universities, undermining both public and private universities in Nigeria.

Essentially, our elite has made nonsense of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria which provides that:

Government shall direct its policy towards ensuring that there are equal and adequate educational opportunities at all levels

Government shall promote science and technology

Government shall strive to eradicate illiteracy; and to this end, Government shall as and when practicable provide:

Free, Compulsory and Universal Primary Education;

Free University Education; and

Free Adult Literacy Programme.

As a nation, we have decided to divert the resources for these to foreign institutions.

The Babcock Convening had drawn out battles between ASUU activists, who see the private universities as the problem, and the private university warriors who see ASUU as the ogre that has killed the public universities with their strikes, forcing the need to go private. I think it would be useful to orient the discussion towards establishing the costs that Nigerians pay to fund and support foreign university budgets. Consciousness of the vastness of the expenditure might push us towards reflecting on how some of the said resources can be used to revive the Nigerian university system. Academic capitalism is not local, it is global. The university as enterprise is not in Nigeria, it is abroad.

A professor of Political Science and development consultant/expert, Jibrin Ibrahim is a Senior Fellow of the Centre for Democracy and Development, and Chair of the Editorial Board of PREMIUM TIMES.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Education

Afe Babalola Send Education Reform Proposals to Tinubu

Published

on

Share

The Founder and Chancellor of the Afe Babalola University Ado-Ekiti (ABUAD), Aare Afe Babalola has announced plans to forward proposals on his idea of quality, functional and impactful education to President Bola Tinubu and other key government officials.

The Founder and Chancellor of the Afe Babalola University Ado-Ekiti (ABUAD), Aare Afe Babalola has announced plans to forward proposals on his idea of quality, functional and impactful education to President Bola Tinubu and other key government officials.

Babalola disclosed this in his letter of appreciation to the Chairman of United Nigeria Airlines, Prof Obiora Okonkwo, who was a Guest Lecturer at the recent convocation ceremony of ABUAD held at university campus in Ado Ekiti.

The legal icon said he had constituted a committee of distinguished academics at ABUAD to examine the contents of the lecture and other related documents, particularly their functionality and relevance to Nigeria’s development.

The committee, according to him, would study Okonkwo’s 14th convocation lecture titled, “Functional Education and the Nigerian Project: Strategic Human Capital Development for National Renewal,” delivered at ABUAD during its 14th convocation ceremony.

The findings, he said, would be transmitted to appropriate authorities, including the President, the Minister of Education, the Minister of Health, the Minister of Agriculture and the Executive Secretary of the National Universities Commission, NUC, for consideration.

Babalola said the initiative was driven by his conviction that Nigeria’s development challenges could not be adequately addressed without quality, functional and impactful education.

He also called on the Federal Government to increase investment in education, while urging wealthy and patriotic Nigerians to emulate the culture of philanthropy prevalent in the United States and Britain, where individuals and institutions support educational establishments.Buy Maps

According to him, sustained private-sector support for education remains critical to building institutions capable of producing globally competitive graduates and addressing national development needs.

He said: “The feelers I have been getting on the well-researched and articulately delivered lecture point to the fact that the lecture was not only well understood, but that its contents will remain indelible in the minds of the audience for a long time to come.”

“It is now obvious that both of us have something in common: How to make this country better. When the result of the findings of my teachers are out, we will send them to the appropriate authorities such as the President and Commander-In-Chief, the Minister of Education, the Minister of Health, the Minister of Agriculture and the Executive Secretary of the National Universities Commission, NUC, among others for them to appreciate the place and import of quality, functional and impactful education.

“Government must be prepared to spend more on Education. Patriotic and well-to-do-Nigerians should emulate then practice in the United States of America and England where well-to-do individuals support private institutions in those countries, that is why our university, Afe Babalola University, Ado-Ekiti, ABUAD, is the clear leader even though it is barely 16 years old”.

Continue Reading

Education

Kohol tasks NUBESS Leaders on Service, Accountability, Legacy

Published

on

Share

By David Torough, Abuja 

The founder of Menroi Rural Priority Organisation, Professor Kohol Iornem has challenged leaders of the National Union of Benue State Students (NUBESS) in the Diaspora to prioritise service delivery, accountability and measurable achievements over the mere pursuit of leadership positions.

Kohol, a Professor of Business Management and John Maxwell Certified Leadership Speaker, Trainer and Coach, gave the charge while delivering a keynote address at the inaugural NUBESS Diaspora Leadership Conference held virtually on November 14, 2026.

Speaking on the theme, “The Essence of Leadership: Making Today’s Opportunities the Foundation for Tomorrow’s Leadership,” he maintained that occupying an executive position does not automatically make one an effective leader, stressing that leadership credibility comes from problems solved, initiatives introduced and lasting improvements achieved.

“A position gives you authority, but your actions give you credibility. Your achievements give you a legacy,” he said.

Prof. Kohol urged chapter presidents to adopt a 90-day leadership challenge involving identifying students’ needs, developing practical solutions, mobilising resources and implementing measurable projects. He also stressed transparency in managing association funds and advised executives to document their achievements as evidence of their leadership experience.

Addressing factionalism and declining student participation in NUBESS activities, the professor recommended neutral mediation and urged leaders to make the association more attractive through scholarships, bursaries, entrepreneurial training, employability skills and career development opportunities.

He also pledged to facilitate entrepreneurial training and connect NUBESS leaders with Benue indigenes in the Diaspora to support student-focused initiatives.

Professor Kohol holds an MBA and PhD from Cardiff Metropolitan University, United Kingdom, and is a Fellow of Advance HE. He currently teaches Business Management at the London College of Contemporary Arts and serves as Director of Programmes at the London Graduate School.

A former Senior Lecturer at Regent College London, he is a member of the British Academy of Management and Fellow of the Institute of Management Consultants. He is also a published author, with his book, A Social Science Student’s Guide to Surviving Your PhD, published by Open University Press.

Beyond academia, Prof. Kohol served as President of Mzough U Tiv United Kingdom (MUTUK) from 2019 to 2023 and founded Menroi Rural Priority Foundation and Mzehemen u Tiv Foundation to promote rural development and improve opportunities for disadvantaged communities in Nigeria.

The conference, convened by NUBESS Diaspora President, Rt. Comr. Tsaha Ernest, in collaboration with the union’s Director of Inter-Camp Affairs, Rt. Comr. Iorwa Timothy Avalumun, also featured Dr Ejeh Sunday of the University of Abuja, who spoke on rebuilding NUBESS through accountability and leadership beyond office positions.

Continue Reading

Business News

NELFUND Loan Improves Graduate’s GPA to 3.50

Published

on

Share

A graduate of the University of Maiduguri, Shianya Ebwaseh, said the Nigerian Education Loan Fund (NELFUND) helped improve her Grade Point Average (GPA) to 3.50 through financial support that enabled her to concentrate on her studies.

Ebwaseh, who graduated from the Department of Zoology, Faculty of Life Sciences, said this in an interview on Monday in Maiduguri.

She said financial difficulties had previously affected her academic performance, as she struggled to meet her daily needs while pursuing her degree.

The graduate said she resorted to selling fried chips and groundnuts on campus to support herself, sometimes missing lectures because of the time and energy required to run the business.

According to her, the introduction of NELFUND’s student loan scheme relieved her financial burden through tuition support and a monthly N20,000 upkeep allowance.

“Before NELFUND, I struggled with my GPA because of financial challenges. I sometimes missed lectures after spending hours frying and packaging chips for sale.

“But when NELFUND came, I stopped the business and concentrated on my studies. My GPA improved to 3.50, which is Second Class Upper,” she said.

Ebwaseh said the financial support also enabled her to attend lectures regularly, purchase learning materials and prepare adequately for tests and examinations without constant worries about money.

She added that her examination scores improved significantly after she began receiving the support, attributing the change to increased concentration and financial stability.

The graduate, who said she accessed the scheme in her third year, described the application process as simple and encouraged other eligible students to apply.

She also said the programme had helped financially disadvantaged students remain in school, particularly those whose parents could not afford tuition fees and upkeep.

Ebwaseh appealed to the Federal Government to sustain the initiative, emphasising that withdrawing the support could expose many students to financial difficulties and possible dropout.

She said the scheme had given beneficiaries an opportunity to pursue their academic ambitions with fewer financial distractions.(NAN)

Continue Reading

Advertisement

Top Stories

NEWS12 hours ago

Morov Community Bans Mining Activities, Inaugurates C’ttee to Investigate Lawful Mining Operations

ShareBy David Torough, Abuja The Morov Community Development Association (MCDA) has resolved to halt all mining activities in the community...

NEWS12 hours ago

Morov Community Bans Mining Activities, Inaugurates C’ttee to Investigate Lawful Mining Operations

ShareBy David Torough, Abuja The Morov Community Development Association (MCDA) has resolved to halt all mining activities in the community...

NEWS13 hours ago

NGX’s Investment in Nairobi Securities Exchange: A New Chapter in Africa’s Capital Market Integration

ShareBy Uche Joe Uwaleke The Nigerian Exchange Group Plc’s (NGX Group) acquisition of a 10 percent strategic stake in the...

NEWS16 hours ago

Customs Moves to Upgrade B’ODOGWU, Targets Cargo Clearance

ShareBy Tambaya Julius, Abuja The Nigeria Customs Service (NCS) has concluded a three-day review of its B’Odogwu Unified Customs Management...

Oil & Gas18 hours ago

NAPE 2026: TotalEnergies Spuds Nigeria’s First Deep Offshore Exploration Well in Decade

ShareTotalEnergies EP Nigeria Limited has commenced drilling of the Akpo Far East B exploration well, days after its Country Chair...

NEWS18 hours ago

Dance as Politics: Dancing to 2027

ShareBy Reuben Abati When a proper audit of the current electoral process is conducted, it would be interesting to evaluate...

NEWS18 hours ago

Oborevwori Woos CAN Support, Promises Land for Prayer Retreat Centre

ShareFrom Francis Sadhere, Delta Delta State Governor, Rt. Hon. Sheriff Oborevwori, has pledged his administration’s support for the proposed Christian...

NEWS18 hours ago

Wike Promotes 4,220 FCT Teachers, 3,494 Other Civil Servants

ShareBy Laide Akinboade, Abuja The Federal Capital Territory (FCT) Minister, Nyesom Wike, on Tuesday approved the promotion of 4,220 Teachers...

NEWS19 hours ago

‎Flag-Off Of Tinubu/Alia 2027 Campaign Benue State

Share‎Benue State is Ready for a New Chapter of Renewed Hope, Consolidated Progress And Greater Development! ‎The Tinubu/Alia Campaign Council...

NEWS19 hours ago

AfDB Approves $102m Facility to Finance SMEs in Nigeria

ShareThe African Development Bank (AfDB) has approved a 102 million dollar financing package for Sterling Bank Nigeria Ltd. to expand...